When Criticism Goes Mainstream: Humayun Saeed Responds to Main Manto Nahi Hoon Backlash
After the criticism aimed at Main Manto Nahi Hoon, actor-turned-producer Humayun Saeed speaks out. The drama incited considerable debate, and his statement is just yet another part of the story. Check out the Six Screen article to get acquainted with all the details.
Drama that Divides
When Main Manto Nahi Hoon aired, there was praise for its rich visual quality and star performances. Audiences admired the rich camera work, direction, and performances, especially those of Saima Noor and Sajal Aly. As time passed, and the initial episode’s grimness started to wear off, social media lit up with voices of concern about some of the drama’s content.
Fat-Shaming and The Line That Was Crossed
One scene raised eyebrows when Sajal’s character lightly referenced Humayun’s character, saying that he must have a “fat wife,” or else there would be a different expression instead of one of low motivation. What was intended as a punchline was seen as body-shaming. Many viewers deemed it outdated and unethical. Online critics, like the senior actors, wanted more sensitivity and better writing from the creators.
The controversies didn’t stop there. There was also worry about the implied romance between Mehmal, being the student, and Manto, the professor. The age and power dynamics felt gross to many. The fandom publicly criticized the normalization of such relationships on television.
Humayun’s Response—With Wit and Respect
In an interview with Ambreen Fatima, Humayun had a pointed yet gentle response. He said, “I laugh at those who criticize me. They take money for what they do. It’s their job. Just like we actors take money for acting.” He urged fans to avoid harassing reviewers. He highlighted that some of these critics are senior actors. That plea came from a place of empathy.
He further stated that debate adds fuel to the drama. He thrives when viewers question the narrative and await answers in future episodes. Humayun praised the drama’s strong script. He stressed that the cast quickly agreed to the project. He said, “Actors aren’t fools. They know what they are doing.” He challenged the critics’ assumptions with confidence and grace.
